Skip to content

Deinstitutionalisation in Practice: A South–North Dialogue across Brazil, Chile and the UK

Published on November 17, 2026

Cristian Montenegro
Workshop participants pose for a group photo

What happens when the principles of community mental health and deinstitutionalisation meet institutional rules, limited resources and the complex social realities of everyday practice?

Workshop participants pose for a group photo

In July 2026, mental health workers and researchers from Brazil, Chile and the UK came together at King’s College London for a two-day workshop organised by the Transitions project, The Ethics and Politics of Psychiatric Deinstitutionalisation in South America.

Rather than organising the exchange around examples of successful interventions or models of good practice, we invited participants to reflect on situations from their own work that they considered difficult, unresolved or ethically challenging. How do professionals navigate competing responsibilities, institutional constraints and uncertainty? What happens when people’s circumstances and needs do not fit neatly within the systems designed to support them?

Our aim was not to identify a model of care that could be transferred between contexts. Instead, we wanted to explore what could be learned by placing different experiences alongside one another: what appears specific to a particular setting, which dilemmas recur across settings, and what these similarities and differences might reveal about deinstitutionalisation in practice.

From different contexts to shared dilemmas

Workshop participants sitting in a circle looking at a flipboard

The workshop was designed around an exchange of experiences rather than a comparison of policies or abstract models of mental health care. Through participatory methods, we wanted to create a space in which the realities of practice - and the ethical dilemmas, uncertainties and questions of responsibility that emerge within them - could become the basis for conversation.

The workshop brought together mental health practitioners, researchers and collaborators from Brazil, Chile and the UK, working across community mental health and inpatient services. This diversity of backgrounds allowed the discussion to move between the practical realities of providing care, the institutional conditions shaping professional work, and broader questions about the politics of mental health reform.

Brief introductions to Brazil, Chile and the UK’s mental health systems situated participants within different histories of mental health reform, institutional arrangements and approaches to deinstitutionalisation. From there, however, we deliberately moved from debates around abstract models of service organisation to concrete situations, in which conflicts and uncertainties set the scene.

Before the workshop, participants had prepared short reflective accounts based on situations from their own practice that they considered difficult, unresolved or ethically challenging. Collected in a booklet and displayed during a "gallery of experiences", these accounts became the core material through which participants encountered one another's work.

Grounding the discussion in concrete situations rather than abstract models changed the terms of the exchange. Instead of asking whether a particular system or intervention could be replicated elsewhere, participants could ask: What would happen in our own contexts? Who would be responsible? What possibilities would be available - or unavailable? What would make this situation different?

Across significant differences between countries and services, familiar tensions emerged around care and control, professional judgement and institutional constraints, the structural causes of distress, and the distribution and coordination of responsibilities for care.

Judgement, recognition and responsibility

A board with documents and post-it notes

These tensions provided the basis for a World Café exercise organised around three themes that had emerged from the earlier discussions.

The first was professional judgement under institutional constraints. What makes good judgement possible when practice is shaped by protocols, organisational priorities, limited resources and concerns about risk? Participants considered the space available for professionals to respond to individual circumstances, as well as what happens when professional judgement and institutional expectations pull in different directions.

The second was recognition, power and unequal care. Whose experiences and needs are most easily overlooked? How do different forms of knowledge and experience acquire legitimacy? These questions opened discussion about how inequalities shape not only who bears a disproportionate burden of illness and who has access to care but also whose accounts are heard, whose needs become visible, and whose perspectives count in decisions about care.

The third was fragmentation and coordination across systems. What happens when people's circumstances cross the boundaries between services, sectors and professional responsibilities? Here, coordination became more than an organisational question. Participants discussed how responsibility is negotiated when no single service or professional role can adequately respond to a person's circumstances.

Bringing deinstitutionalisation back to everyday practice

For Transitions, these conversations connect directly with a central concern of the project: understanding deinstitutionalisation not only through policies, institutions and histories of reform, but also through the practices and relationships by which reform is made - and contested - in everyday life.

The workshop brought into focus what happens between broad commitments to community-based mental health care and the institutional conditions under which people actually work and receive support. Participants discussed situations in which people moved between services without finding a clear place within them; professionals encountered responsibilities extending beyond their formal remit; and community-based responses were themselves shaped by scarce resources, organisational pressures and wider social inequalities.

Placing experiences from Brazil, Chile and the UK alongside one another did not produce a common model or a set of transferable solutions. Instead, the exchange helped make both similarities and differences more visible. Problems that appeared familiar could have quite different institutional histories; practices that seemed self-evident in one context could look unusual from another.

This is particularly important for a project concerned with the international histories and contemporary politics of psychiatric reform. South–North dialogue need not mean searching for practices that can simply be exported from one setting to another. It can also provide a way of questioning what has become taken for granted within our own systems.

From exchange to continuing conversation

Workshop participants stand in discussion with a large, empty screen in the background.

The workshop ended without attempting to turn two days of discussion into a consensus statement. Participants instead reflected on what they might take back to their own work, which questions deserved further attention, and whether particular conversations or connections might continue beyond the workshop.

On the final afternoon, participants visited two mental health services in East London: an inpatient psychiatric ward at Homerton University Hospital, hosted by Jacob Clark, and the Barnsley Street Neighbourhood Mental Health Centre in Bethnal Green, hosted by Cassandra Geisel. The visits offered opportunities to explore contrasting but interconnected approaches to inpatient and community-based care, and to continue discussions about institutional constraints, professional responsibilities and the possibilities of community-oriented support in everyday practice.

For Transitions, one of the most valuable aspects of the workshop was the opportunity to bring academic research into conversation with experiences, perspectives and forms of knowledge that do not often meet in the same room. The exchange reinforced the importance of creating spaces where practitioners and researchers can think together about the contradictions of deinstitutionalisation, without assuming that these can be resolved through a single model or set of recommendations.

The conversations also opened questions that will continue to inform our research: how community-based care is negotiated within institutional constraints, how responsibility is distributed across fragmented systems, and how experiences from different contexts can challenge what we take for granted about psychiatric reform. We hope to continue developing these exchanges as the project progresses.